Upvotecast
Example subreddit analysis

r/marketing

For marketing communications + advertising industry professionals to discuss and ask questions related to marketing strategy, media planning, digital, social, search, campaigns, data science, email, user experience, content, copywriting, segmentation, attribution, data visualization, testing, optimization, and martech. We are a support network for people working at brands, businesses, agencies, vendors, and academia.

1,972,025 membersAnalyzed on September 25, 2026

Self-promotion

Strict on self-promotion

Rule 1 imposes a zero-tolerance permanent ban on advertising and self-promotion, and Rule 7 explicitly removes posts that read as shilling, a product ask, or a 'link with a few sentences'; Rule 9 also bans website/product review requests, so any promotional framing gets removed fast.

Patterns that work

Recurring patterns in the top posts of the past year. Counts and scores are measured from those posts.

Based on 94 top posts. Left out 6 moderator, pinned or recurring posts.

  1. Score lift
    1.0×
    About the same

    Career burnout or exit confession

    17 of 94 top posts 18%

    A first-person post describing exhaustion, disillusionment, or wanting to leave the marketing profession.

    Why it works: Resonates broadly since most readers are working marketers who share similar frustrations, driving high comment counts.

    Top posts using it
  2. Score lift
    1.8×

    Ad/creative critique with image

    16 of 94 top posts 17%

    An image of a real ad or campaign posted with a short caption inviting judgment or reaction.

    Why it works: Visual, concrete, and easy for professionals to critique or praise without needing more context.

    Top posts using it
  3. Score lift
    1.4×

    AI anxiety or backlash post

    13 of 94 top posts 14%

    A post complaining about, warning against, or mocking AI's growing role in marketing work or content.

    Why it works: Taps into widespread professional insecurity and identity threat that generates strong opinions and long threads.

    Top posts using it

How top posts are laid out

Top text posts open with a short first-person statement of the situation or feeling, then add two to four short paragraphs or bullets of context, and end with a direct question or open invitation for others to weigh in.

  1. One or two sentence hook stating the emotion or situation
  2. Brief background on the poster's role, tenure, or industry context
  3. A short story or specific incident illustrating the problem
  4. Optional bullet list of specific frustrations or details
  5. A direct closing question inviting others' experiences or opinions

Best times to post

Top posts by hour · US Eastern
12am6am12pm6pm12am
  1. #1 Mon, 10–11am ET
  2. #2 Wed, 3–4pm ET
  3. #3 Thu, 3–4pm ET
0 top posts4 in one hour

When the top 94 posts of the past year were published, in US Eastern time. Each square counts the posts that went up in that hour.

Left out 6 moderator, pinned or recurring posts.

What formats win

Format of top posts
  • Text
    62%
  • Image
    34%
  • Link
    4%

Share of the top 94 posts of the past year by post type.

Typical text post
134words
Middle half: 70–242 words
Median comments
106
Per top post

What top titles have in common

  • Many titles pose a direct question to the community, often ending in a question mark ("Why do so many marketing departments feel like a girls club?")
  • Personal confession or vent framed as a first-person statement ("I love marketing…but I hate working in marketing")
  • Ad or campaign critique presented as a short observational caption ("No CTA, no brand, ad on the London tube")
  • Career-crisis or layoff disclosure stated plainly without embellishment ("Just got laid off. Now what?")
  • AI-in-marketing anxiety or complaint stated as a blunt claim or rant ("ChatGPT briefs are driving me crazy")

The culture

This is a working-professionals' hangout more than a strategy forum: the loudest threads are about the emotional and structural strain of doing marketing for a living, not tactical how-tos, and skepticism toward AI, gurus, and hype runs deep throughout the top content.

The subreddit rewards vivid ad critiques with images, honest career venting, and direct questions that invite peer experience, while it ignores or removes generic advice-seeking, blog links, product pitches, and anything that reads as promotional or beginner-level.

Do

  • Post real ad or campaign images with a short, opinionated caption rather than a long write-up
  • Frame career or workplace posts as honest first-person accounts, not generic advice requests
  • Ask specific, narrow questions rather than broad 'teach me marketing' prompts
  • Use a plain, descriptive title that states the topic or tension up front
  • Keep any promotional content out entirely; discuss brands and tools only in a critique or discussion context, never as your own offering

Don't

  • Don't link to your own blog, product, app, or service, even briefly, per the zero-tolerance self-promo rule
  • Don't ask for app feedback, product reviews, or 'would you pay for this' validation
  • Don't post beginner or 'how do I get into marketing' questions meant for r/AskMarketing
  • Don't post AI-generated writing or obvious AI-written briefs as your submission text
  • Don't post surveys, homework questions, or job-search/resume-help requests

Rules (14)

  1. 01Advertising, Self-Promotion, & Spam (Permanent Ban)

    If you want to advertise in this community, have a look at reddit.com/advertising. We have a zero tolerance policy to Advertising, Self-Promotion, & Spam.

  2. 02AI Generated Content (Permanent Ban)

    This is a subreddit for humans, not bots, so please don't copy and paste AI generated content. We have a zero tolerance policy to AI generated content.

  3. 03App Ideas & Feedback (Permanent Ban)

    This includes any sort of "would you pay for this app/feature/service" post.

  4. 04Research Surveys & Homework Help (Post Removal)

    Don't post them.

  5. 05New To Marketing (Post Removal)

    r/Marketing is for marketing professionals to discuss and ask questions related to the marketing industry. Please ask beginner questions in r/AskMarketing,

  6. 06Job Hunting, Interview & Resume Feedback (Post Removal)

    We know it can be difficult to find a marketing job, but please don't ask us to help you find a job.

  7. 07Low Quality (Post Removal & Possible Ban)

    We're trying to build something great here, help us do that. A post or comment in a poor attempt to shill or sell a product or service, is someone's homework, is asking a question which has already been answered many times, is looking for free marketing instead of paying for a professional, or is a few sentences with a link to their blog. Let's not forget, memes, rants without a source, screenshots, etc. will all be removed.

  8. 08Non-Specific Resource Request (Post Removal)

    E.G. "I'm thinking about marketing, teach me." Be respectful of the community by searching the posts and asking specific questions.

  9. 09Website/Product Reviews (Post Removal & Possible Ban)

    Please don't ask us to review or give feedback for your website or product.

  10. 10URL Shorteners (Post Removal & Possible Ban)

    Any post or comment using a URL shortener will be removed.

  11. 11Abuse/Rudeness (Post Removal & Possible Ban)

    This is a nice subreddit, where people are nice to each other. Abuse and rudeness are unwelcome, and may result in a ban.

  12. 12Posts Must Use A Descriptive Title (Post Removal)

    Help your fellow Redditors understand what your post is about.

  13. 13Posting And Commenting Is Restricted To Accounts Over 30 Days Old With 300+ Combined Karma Points

    Posts and comments from accounts which don't meet this threshold will be automatically removed.

  14. 14No Politics (Post Removal & Possible Ban)

    This is a nice subreddit with people from all walks of life. Therefore we do not allow political posts as they *always* devolve into fighting and abuse.

Top posts this month

  1. Indeed CMO: Marketing jobs have fallen faster than ‘almost any other white-collar function’
    370 upvotes100 commentslink
  2. Marketing tactics or someone has a hangover and forgot to test?
    253 upvotes74 commentsimage
  3. Is Gary Vee finally disgraced from the mainstream?
    212 upvotes203 commentstext
  4. Someone left this comment under my post on LinkedIn I'm really tired of those people
    153 upvotes165 commentsimage
  5. Got Fired Due to Shitty Marketing
    109 upvotes59 commentstext
  6. Marketers who have made it to really senior roles – what's the one thing you still don't understand or know how to do that you definitely should understand or know how to do?
    105 upvotes103 commentstext
  7. I accidentally hit 200k followers
    88 upvotes52 commentstext
  8. Is content marketing dead? Seeing no light at the end of the tunnel today
    86 upvotes197 commentstext
  9. Feeling like arts & craft "department"
    75 upvotes46 commentstext
  10. Would you return to agency life after going brand-side?
    61 upvotes107 commentstext

Similar subreddits

  • r/AskMarketing
  • r/advertising
  • r/digital_marketing
  • r/DigitalMarketing
  • r/content_marketing
Free to start

Want this for any subreddit?

Know what works before you write: rules, self-promo limits, timing, formats and culture for the communities you care about. Then check your draft against them before you post.

Join the waitlist3 analyses a month on the free plan. No card needed.